Fixed annuity payout options: Choosing your ideal settlement

Purchasing a fixed annuity can be a smart move toward long-term financial security. However, the an important decision comes after the purchase: choosing how you’ll receive your payments. Understanding your annuity settlement options (also called annuitization options) impacts both your monthly income and what you can leave behind for your beneficiaries.

This guide defines what annuity payments are, explains when and how you can cash out an annuity, and evaluates key factors influencing the best fixed annuity payout option for you. Plus, you’ll see how Gainbridge’s annuity calculators enable you to compare options side by side, helping project your retirement income and potential inheritance scenarios before you commit.

What are annuity settlement options?

Annuity settlement options are the contractual choices that determine when your payments begin, how long they last, and who receives them. These decisions can turn your annuity investment into a reliable stream of retirement income. And because settlement options can shape both your financial security and the legacy you leave behind, choosing how you receive your payments can be one of the most important decisions you’ll make.

Typically, annuity payment options come in two forms: 

• Lump sum: A single, one-time payment that can give you immediate access to your annuity value, but forgoes further compound growth and steady cash flow in retirement. 
• Periodic payouts (annuitization): The conversion of your annuity into a series of payments spread out over a specified time period or for life. 

Now, let’s look at how annuity payments work in real life and walk through practical scenarios to help you choose the option that fits your needs.

How do annuity payments work?

Annuity payments combine the return of your principal investment with the interest it earned over time. If you own a non-qualified annuity (meaning you purchased with after-tax money), the Internal Revenue Service (IRS) taxes only the earnings portion of your annuity as ordinary income. Because you already paid tax on the principal, you get it back tax-free. If you purchased an annuity with pre-tax money or is a qualified annuity, the whole amount of principal plus interest will be taxed. 

You can typically elect monthly, quarterly, or annual annuity payments. They can start immediately (within one year of your contribution) or be deferred, often to retirement. 

Why does annuity growth matter when choosing a payout option?

Fixed annuities are popular among retirement investors because they offer a guaranteed interest rate. With a fixed annuity, you don’t have to worry about market downturns; your interest rate is locked in, so stock market volatility won’t impact your growth. You know exactly how much you’ll earn over time, which makes it easier to decide how you want to receive your annuity payments later on. 

Consider, for instance, a $50,000 contribution in Gainbridge’s SteadyPace™ fixed annuity, a product built for steady, predictable growth. Over 10 years, those funds can grow to about $83,405, including roughly $33,405 in interest. The annuity payout option you choose for that $83,405 will influence the size and frequency of some of your retirement income. In most cases, you’re choosing between maximizing your income during your lifetime or ensuring that a portion remains for your beneficiary.

Common annuity payout options

When it’s time to start receiving income from your annuity, you’ll usually choose from a few standard payout structures:

• Straight life annuity: With a straight life annuity, you’ll receive regular payments for as long as you live. However, when you pass away, the payments end. This option typically means higher payouts but leaves nothing for your beneficiaries.
• Period certain annuity: A period certain annuity (a fixed period annuity settlement option) guarantees payments for a predetermined time period — usually five, 10, or 20 years. If you pass before the term ends, your beneficiary receives the remaining value, either as a lump sum or as continued payments.
  

Choosing the right payout option depends on your financial needs, your life expectancy, and whether leaving money to a beneficiary is a priority. Understanding these options can help you make an informed decision about your retirement income.

Choosing the right payout option: 3 considerations

The best annuity payout option for you depends on the details of your financial situation, especially how you weigh the following key factors.

1. Income needs

Your income needs in retirement come down to two questions: 

• How much money do you need in retirement and for how long?
• Do you need to ensure that your annuity takes care of a beneficiary, such as a spouse? 
  

If your main concern is running out of money, a straight life annuity can make sense. If you live longer than expected, you don’t have to worry about your income stream evaporating. However, if Social Security, an individual retirement account (IRA), or other sources already cover most of your expenses and you want to leave money for your beneficiaries, a period certain annuity may be the better choice.

2. Longevity protection

This ties back to your life expectancy and the odds that you’ll outlive your retirement savings. In addition to the choice between straight life and period certain annuities, some retirees choose a joint and survivor annuity. While this option generally provides slightly smaller monthly payments, it guarantees ongoing income for both spouses. When you pass away, your spouse continues to receive 100%, 75%, or 50% of the monthly benefit you were receiving.

3. Tax situation

Your future tax bracket and the type of account your annuity sits in can significantly shape your annuitization strategy. If you own a qualified annuity — one funded with pre-tax dollars through an account like an IRA — the IRS taxes the full amount of each payment. By contrast, with a non-qualified annuity funded with after-tax dollars, only your earnings are taxable, while your principal comes back to you tax-free.

Your expected tax bracket in retirement can help guide how you structure your annuity payouts. As a general rule, smaller payments over time tend to mean smaller yearly tax bills, while larger checks can push your taxable income higher. 

With help from a tax or financial advisor, you can select the option that aligns your annuity income with your overall retirement income.

Simplify your retirement plan with Gainbridge 

The annuity payout decision ultimately comes down to balancing two priorities: ensuring you don’t run out of money in retirement and leaving enough to support your loved ones after you’re gone. Choosing between maximizing your lifetime income and protecting your beneficiaries requires thoughtful planning and a careful look at your full financial picture.

Gainbridge can help eliminate some of the uncertainty. Our fixed annuities can provide guaranteed interest rates, shielded from market volatility. Use our annuity payout calculator to model different scenarios and determine how much income your annuity will provide and for how long. A fixed annuity from Gainbridge seamlessly converts to a stream of reliable retirement income — no surprises, no hidden fees or commissions. 

Explore Gainbridge today to learn how our fixed annuities can help you build a flexible retirement strategy, protecting you and your family with guaranteed payments.

‍

This article is intended for informational purposes only. It is not intended to provide, and should not be interpreted as, individualized investment, legal, or tax advice. For advice concerning your own situation please contact the appropriate professional. The GainbridgeⓇ digital platform provides informational and educational resources intended only for self-directed purposes. Guarantees are backed by the financial strength and claims-paying ability of the issuer.

‍